|
THE RASTAFARIANS: FOR EXACT REFERENCE: We advise that you buy the book, it's
easy to find online. It's also the perfect Idea for a reggae present BUY
IT NOW (from the Publisher)
Chapter 2 / Domination and Resistance in Jamaican History
The Jamaican Maroon: a Study of Fight and Flight
Fighting Method
The Peace Treaty of March 1, 1738
The Effects of the Treaty
The Sam Sharpe Rebellion: 1831 - 32
The War
The Aftermath
The Morant Bay Rebellion, 1865
Paul Bogle
Crown Colony to Independence 1865 - 1962
Garvey and the Rastafarians
Jamaicans are by nature some of the most fun loving, hardworking, and gregarious
people in the Caribbean. Threated with kindness and respect, they are likely
to remain the most confident and dependable friends on earth. but if treated
with impunity and disrespect, all the rage of a deep psychic revenge may surface
with unpredictable consequences. This calm-and-storm personality of contemporary
Jamaicans is a direct inheritance from that group of Africans who suffered the
most frustrating and oppressive slavery ever experienced in a British colony.
The early history of Jamaica is one long tale of sad intrigue, human suffering,
lawlessness, and immoral profit, at the center of which were th African slaves
- the ancestors of present-day Jamaicans. Slavery in Jamaica lacked any vestige
of humanity. A handful of greedy planters held absolute power over thousnds
of slaves. Only through violence could such domplete domination by a minority
be initiated and perpetuated. So in Jamaica, as in North America, the psychology
of slave control was highly developed, and in Frederick Douglass's words, "Fear,
awe, and bedience became interwoven into the very nature of the slaves."
Under such complete domination two reactions were provoked: fight and flight.
This chapter will study these two reactions in an attempt to analyze how these
survival techniques aided in breaking the chains of their ancestors and descendants.
I shall also show that these behavior patterns (and their consequences) are
directly responsible for the independent Jamaica of today, and that these patterns
still remain a part of the Jamaican's psychic reactions to life. Beginning with
the emergence of the Maroons, we shall review the prominent freedom movements
from the seventeenth century to the emergence of the Rastafarian movement during
the twentieth century.
The Jamaican Maroon: a Study of Fight and Flight
The evidence is now well documented that the Africans who were carried to the
Caribbean resisted their enslavement and continued to resist their bondage both
passively and violently up until the abolition of slavery and beyond. The classic
example of this resistance is the presence of Maroon communities all over the
New World. It is only recently that Maroon history has become accessible, but
the historical events of the Jamaican Maroons were probalby some of the earliest
to be recorded. Their fame as freedom fighters and their elusiveness (assisted
by the mountain fastnes of the Jamaican hill country) forced the British to
sue for peace as early as 1738. In this way, the Jamaica Maroon communities
existedas a free people sixty-six years before the independence of haiti and
ninety-six years before slavery was abolished on the island.
The story of the Jamaican Maroon begins with the English defeat of Spain in
1655. The Spaniards, finding themselves outclassed by the British, sailed from
the nort coast of Jamaica for Cuba and left their slaves to the British. But
the slaves had ideas of their own. Although we have no true records of the treatment
of Spanish slaves in Jamaica up to 1655, we may assume from the behavior of
the Spanish slaves that they were discontent with slavery, for they soon sought
freedom in the hill country where they fought a grueling war to the death. These
Spanish slaves came to be called "Maroons". The origin of the word
derives from both French and Spanish and carries the same connotation in both;
that is, as hunters of wild animals - probably the wild pigs and wild cattle
native to the mountains on the island. Later, the word took on the conotations
of wildness and fierceness and soon the maroons were themselves known as the
wild and fierce ones. The first Maroons were under the leadership of Juan de
Bolas (immortalized by a village bearing his name near the borders of St. Catherine
and Clarendon). In 1663 , after eight years of harassing the British, an attempt
was made to pacify them. Juan de Bolas was made a colonel by the British and
was sent to his followers to sue for peace. The Maroons correctly perceived
the whole matter as a deception to re-enslave them: they ambushed their chief
and, according to Bryan Edwards, "He was cut to pieces."
Other pockets of runaway slaves began to develop in the eastern and northern
parts of the island, most of them new recruits from Africa, especially from
the Gold Coast. These were called Coromantees - slaves shipped from the Koromantyn
slave castle situated near Elmina on the Cape Coast of present-day Ghana. They
were mostly mixtures of Ashanti and Fanti and sold into slavery during the development
of the Ashanti Federation. Since most were prisoners of war, they were well
trained in guerrilla fighting which was to become an important part of teir
lives. many of these runaway slaves took refuge in the hills and joined forces
with the original Maroons. The Planter historian Edward Long states:
"With the importation of slaves inby the English, almost from the start
irrepressible spirits among the Koromantyn fled to the mountains and found refuge
with the Maroons in such numbers that they soon gained control of the entire
body."
Amont the "irrepressible spirits" was an Ashanti family who was carried
to Jamaica. The family membes were Cudjoe, Johnny (who seemed to have adopted
an English name quite early), Accompong, Cofi (spelled Cuffee in Jamaican documents),
and Quaco. All appear to have been fighters in Africa. According to Long, Cudjoe
had exemplified himself as a leader as early as 1693 and had organized most
of the Maroons under his leadership. The life or death struggle for freedom
had begun. There weems to have been little difference between the Spanish Maroons
and the Koromantyns in manners and language, and even the other tribal groups
who joined them soon overcame their differences and adopted the Ashanti language.
R.C. Dallas, who wrote the first full-length history of the Maroons, observed:
"The Coromantee language, however, superseded the others, and became in
time the general one used."
Cudjoe, on assuming his command, appointed his brothrs Accompong and Johnny
to be leaders under him, and named Cuffee and Quaco subordinate captains. The
brunt of the Maroon campain was carried on under these five men and were assisted
by others, mainly in the northern and southern parts of Jamaica. On the east
side of the island, another sizable group of Maroons formed under the leadership
of the legendary Acheampong Nanny who was said to be either the wife or the
sister of Cudjoe. Not much is known of her, but there is a town named in her
nonor in that point of the island, and her fame has been so great in Jamaican
folk tradition that the legislature has posthumously named her the first womand
to receive the distinction of National Hero in the year 1975. but if nothing
is known of Nanny, much is known of her colleague in command, Captain Quaco,
who later supervised the signing of the treaty with the English for that group
of Maroons in 1739.
Fighting Method
The terror the Maroons caused the English in the seventeenth and eighteenth
centuries was far greater than what the Maroons could have commanded in size
alone. (it is believed that at no time did their number exceed on thousand five
hundred.) But the deployment of small groups by Cudjoe in sudden and savage
attack and swift withrrawal kept the English completely disoriented about their
strngth. Their ability to use the rugged mountain terrain provided another effective
strategy. Their excellent intelligence network being sent against them. Dallas,
speaking of their guerrilla tactics, observed:
"Such are the natural fortifications in which the Maroons secured themselves
in times of danger, and from which it has been ever found difficult to dislodge
them. (their camps were always situated at the mouth of a rock( which look like
a geat fissure made through someextraordinary convulsion of nature, and through
which men can pass only in a single file, the Maroons, whenever they expect
an attack, disposed of themselves on the ledges of the rocks on both sides.
Sometimes they advanced a party beyond the entrance of the defile, frequently
in a line on each side , if the ground would admit; and lay covered by th underwood,
and behind rocks and roots of trees, waiting insilent ambush for their pursuers,
of whose approach they ahd always information from their scouts."
Such strategies at this period were unknown to the English army whose philosophy
of warfare was that of the gentleman soldier. One historian of the period contrasted
the English soldiers with the Maroons as follows:
"The British trops marched in their proper regimentals, as if they were
going to fight a rdegular and civilized enemy, and sometiems had even the absurdity
to traverse the mountainous roads with drums beating. The customary accoutrements
were too mclumsy and burdensome for traversing the woods and clambering over
rocks, and the red coats were too conspicuous and object to the Maroons marksmen,
who seldom missed their aim."
After nearly forty-five years of fighting a losing battle and aftger nearly
a quarter of a million pounds and hundreds of lives taken, Governor Trelawny
was urged to offer peace to the Maroons. This advice was politically fruitful
for the English, and it later destroyed the image of the Maroons as a symbol
of freedom.
The Peace Treaty of March 1, 1738
Leaving out all the drama surrounding the sighing of the treaty, I shall present
only the main articles of theis historical documents, beginning with the preamble
about the king and God's displeasure over he shedding of blood. The treaty contains
fifteen articles:
First, That all hostilities shall cease on both sides forever.
Second, That the said Captain Cudjoe, the rest of his captains, adherents, and
men, shall be forever hereafter in a perfect sate of freedom and liberty, excepting
htose who have been taken by them, within two years last past, if such are willing
to return to their said masters and owners, with full pardon and indemnity...
provided always, that if they are not willing to return, they shall remain in
subject to Captain Cudjoe and in friendship with us, according to the form and
tenor or this treaty.
Third, That they shall enjoy and possess, for themselves and posterity forever,
all the lands situated and tying between Trelawny Town and the Cockpits, to
the amount of fifteen hundres acres bearing North-West from the said Trelawny
Town.
Fourth, That they shall have liberty to plant the said lands with coffee, cocoa,
ginger, tobacco, and cotton, and to bred cattle, hogs goats, or any other flock
and dispose of the produce or increase of the said cmmodities to the inhabitants
of this island; provided always, that when they bring the said commodities to
market, they shall apply first to the custos, or any other magistrate of the
respective parishes where they expose their goods to sale, for license to sell
the same.
Fifth, That Captain Cudjoe, and all the Captain's adherents, and people now
in subjection to him, shall all live together within the bounds of Trelawny
Town, and that they shall have liberty to huynt where they shall think fit,
except within three miles of any settlement, crawl, or pen; provided always
that in case of the hunters of Captain Cudjoe, and those of other settlements
meet, then the hogs oare to be equally divided between both parties.
Sixth, That the said Captain Cudjoe, and his successors, do use their best endeavours
to take, kill, suppress, or destroy, either by themselves, or jointly with any
other number of men, commande on that service by His Excellency the governor,
or Commander-in-Chief for the time being, all rebels wheresoever they be, throughout
this island, unless they submit to the same terms of accomodation granted to
Captain Cudjoe, and his successors.
Seventh, That in case this island be invaded by any foreigh enemy, the said
Captian Cudjoe, and his sucessors gereinafter named or to be appointed, shall
then upon notice biven, immediately erpair to any place the Governor for the
time being shall appoint, in order to repel the said invaders with his or their
utmost force, and to submit to the orders of teh Commander in chief on that
occasion.
Eighth, That if any white man shall doany manner of injury to Captain Joe, his
successors, or any of his or their people, they shall applyto any commanding
officer or magistrate in the neighbourhood for justice; and in casde Captain
Cudjoe, or any of his people shall do any injury to any white person he shall
submit himself, or deliver up such person to justice.
Ninth, That if any begroes shall hereafter run away from their masters or owners,
and fall in Captain Cudjoe's hands, they shall immediately ben sent back to
the chief magistrate of teh next parish where they are taken; and those that
bring them are to be satisfied for their trouble, as the legislature shall appoint.
Tenth, That all negroes taken, since the raising of this party by Captain Cudjoe
and his successors, shall wait on His Excellency, or the Commander in Chief
for the time being every year, if thereunto required.
Twelfth, That Captain Cudjoe, during his life, and the Captains succeeding him,
shall have full power to inflict any punishment they think proper for crimes
committed by their men among themselves, death only excepted; in which case,
if the Captain thinks they deserve death, he shall be obliged to bring them
before any justice of the peace, who shall order proceeding s on their trial
equal to those of any other negroes.
Thirteenth, That Captain Cudjoe with his people, shall cut, clear, and keep
open, large and convenient roads from Trelawny Town to Westmoreland and St.
James's, and if possible, to St. Elizabeth's.
Fourteenth, That two white men, to be nominated by His Excellency, or the Commander
in Chief for the time being, shall constantly live and reside with Captain Cudjoe,
and his successors, in order to maintain a friendly correspondence with the
inhabitants of this island.
Fifteenth, That Captain Cudjoe shall, during his life, be chief Commander in
Trelawny Town; after his cecease the command to devolve on his brother Captain
Accompong; and in case of his decease, on his next brother Captain Johnny; and
failing him, Captain Cuffee shall succeed; who is to be succeeed by Captain
Quaco; and after their demise, the Governor or Commander in chief for the time
being, shall appoint, from time to time, whom he thinks fit for that command.
The Effects of the Treaty
The treaty brought an end to hostilities between the Planters and the fighting
Maroons. It made them a free people with their own lands and leaders and created
for them a mystical sophistication which has continued to the present day. But
a careful reading of the treaty shows quite clearly that for the Maroons it
was a pyrrhic victory, the greatest advantages falling into the hands of the
English settlers. The treaty reduced the fighting Maroons from gallant freedom
fighters to an unpaid army of English Planters and a permanent police force,
a duty which they willingly performed up to the Rebellion of 1865.
The effects of the treaty on the plantation slaves were devastating. The sixth
and ninth articles of the treaty were supported by the Maroons to the letter
and, on the basis of this loyalty, every bid for freedom by the slaves and free
Jamaicans - even after the emancipation - was successfully crushed by the Maroons.
As the following events prove, of the thousands of Blacks whose blood was spilled
for freedom in jamaica afger the sighing of this treaty, the Maroons far oudid
the British militia, who depended on them to do the dirty work while praising
and damning their savagery at the same time. Jamaican history should record
that the gallantry of the Trelawny Maroons ceased with the sighing of the Peace
Treaty of March 1, 1738, and that of the leeward maroons of July 23, 1739. The
history of the Maroons, thereafter, has been a sad tale of atrocities perpetuated
agains their countrymen. After the sighing of the treaties, the Maroons became
traitors to freedom and have contributed very little to the development of the
island. For the most part, they have remained secluded from the rest of the
society in their haunted mountains, living on the recollection of a dead past.
On my recent visti to Accompong in 1973, I saw what appeared to be a conscious
awareness of a crippling stagnation, esxpecially among the young Maroons. They
were very critical of the leadership of their people and showed their resentment
by disrupting the rituals of their most cherished festival by shrowing away
the meat that had been painstakingly cooked for the traditional feast. the Rastafarians
often prais the Maroons, but are also selective in their praise. Cudjoe, Quaco,
and Nanny receive their honor. The Rastafarians - avid reders of Jamaican history
- seem clearly to understand that the maroons (after Cudjoe and his general)sold
out to theBritish and failed to set an example for movements of liberation to
follow. It is no wonder that the Rastas to this day have resisted any prominent
leadership. They have repeatedly expessed to me that they are afraid that leaders
of the movement would only"sell us out." I have no doubt in my mind
that the maroons experience lingers in their memory.
Despite the treaties of 1738-39, very little was done to see that the provisions
of the Maroons were carried out. The English, having disposed of an immediate
problem, applied themselves to makein money on their plantations. Lulled into
complacency, the Maroons went about their busines, trying as best they could
to exist on the worst pieces of lands in Jamaica. It was only a matter of time
before the peace of 1738 was to turn against the Trelawny Maroons; by 1795,
they had been reduced to humble peasants. The white superintendent placed among
them saw no threat to the government by the Maroons and so he spent long periods
away from his post. The Maroon lands had become so overcrowded and fruitless
that the Trelawnys were actually starving. Their whit eresident captain, Mr.
James, was finally replaced by Captain Craskell, whom the Maroons disliked.
Insubordiation mounted daily until finally in mid-july of that year, Captain
Craskell was driven out. but the coup de grace of the whole episode was the
beating of two Maroons (in Montego Bay), as sentenced by a regularly constituted
court, for having stolen 2 pigs. Although the penalty was a regular one, the
flogging was done by a runaway slave: both an affront and grave insult to the
proud Maroons. All of this led to a renewal of war between the Trelawny Maroons
and the colonial government. by this time however, the Maroons had neither the
united front nor the gallantry of past years. Forty-six years had passed since
the peace treaty had been signed. A sectoin of the Maroons under Captain Accompong
had settled in the Nassau Mountains in a town that now bears his name. They
refused to support the Trelawnys on account of some differences that had defeloped.
Instead, the Accompongs joined forces with the colonialists, and the fate of
the Trelawnys was sealed. After a short but vigourous battle they surrendered
and six hundred of them were transported to Halifax on June 7, 1796; finding
the place unsuitable for Blacks, however, the colonial government - in agreement
with Sierra Leone - removed them to Freetown, West Africa. I will retrun to
the subject of the Maroons who remained in Jamaica, but for now I will discuss
one of the most important attempts at freedom in Jamaica - made by the regular
estate slaves rather than by the Maroons.
The Sam Sharpe Rebellion: 1831 - 32
Chattel Slavery was enourmously profitable. In the seventeenth and eighteenth
centuries the epithet, "as wealthy as a West Indian," was given to
a body of English Planters who grew rich and powerful though ther enormous profits
on Caribbean investments in slaves and sugar. But if Slaveholding was profitable,
itwas always at the expense of peace of nimd, deep forebondings, and an unpredictable
future, because the slaves were always a "troublesome property." In
Jamaica, as the record will show, not a year passed between the seventeenth
and the nineteenth centuries without a rebellion or at least the threat of one.
Even when no overt rebellion (taht demanded the militia) took place, the covert
or passive rebellion was equally disruptive and always present.
The dawning of the nineteenth century saw the twilight of "the peculiar
institution" -slavery. The French Revolution had just taken place and commoners
everywhere in Europe saw the citadels of privilege suddenly coming to ruin.
In the Caribbean, the Haitian slaves had freed themselves form their long night
of slavery, proving to the army of Napoleon that they not only desired freedom,
but were also willing to die for it. In England, the anti-Slavery Society would
soon put an end to the commerce in human flesh. In the West Indies, the mighty
Planters suddenly saw the handwriting on the wall. This sudden change in the
social, politica, and economic arena of Europe and the Caribbean threatened
to ruin those who invested heavily in the slave trade. As a result, the Planters
began to muster all their weapons against what they considered to be the irrational
sentiments of the humanitarians and missionaries. Between the proslavery and
the propagandists opened the nineteenth century with a sculrrilous attack on
the sentimentality of hte humanitarians , the rationality of slavery, and the
gorss inferiority of Africans whose only hope of redemption from savagery was
by way of servitude.
The Jamaican slaves in the nineteenth century were not entirely ignorant of
these developments. Many of them wre able to follow the controversy in the local
papers and communicate it ot their illiterate brethren. Many servants also overheard
the heated discussions on their fate as their ungurarded and enraged masters
poured out their vitrio against their pending demise. Samuel Sharpe was one
slave who was well-equipped both mentally and emotionally to follow the controversy;
in 1831, he inspired one of the most extensive rebellions on the island of Jamaica.
Partly because of this rebellion, the King of England hastened the emancipation
of the slaves in Jamaica in 1834. According ot Henry Bleby, an eyewitness to
this insurrectoin, evidence taken by the Royal Commission after the rebellion
"demonstrated to the Imperial legislature, that among the negroes themselves
the spirit of freedom had been so widely diffused as to render it most perilous
to postpone the settlement of the important question of emancipatoin to a later
period. " This widespread spirit of freedom resulted from a variety of
sources, for esxample, a large number of the slaves had become Christians and
literate enough to assume lay leadership, most of them of the Methodis and Baptist
faith. Of th Baptists, there were two varieties: thost of hte London Baptist
Missions, staffed by White missionaries; and the native Baptists, the older
variety, founded by George Liele. Liele - an American Baptist slave-preacher
taken to Jamaica after the American revolution - started a thriving Baptist
mission on the island. The Native Baptists grafted Christianity to the African
ethos of the slaves and took on a messianic millenarian fervor. This spiritual
combination became the energizing force behind th eslaves in their demand for
freedom as a command from God.
Sam Sharpe was said to be a member of th london Baptist Mission of Montego Bay,
but the author believes that he was also a leader in the Native Baptits church.
It appears that the groundwork for the rebellion was laid in a prayer meeting.
Henry Bleby, who interviewed the prisoners after the insurrection for the rebellion
Committee, is our only source on this matter. One of the men he interviewed
was Edward Hylton, whom he referred to as "one of the original conspirators."
According to Hylton, sometime during 1831 (he could not remember the month),
he received an invitation trom Sam Sharpe - a slave at the Retrieve Estates
near Montego Bay - to attend a meeting at the home of Mr Johnson on the same
estate. After prayer, most of the members left the house leaving onlyu Sharpe,
Johnson, and Hylton. Soon these three were joined by others who approached "under
extreme caution." According to Hylton, Sharpe was expecting htese people.
After they had safely assembled, Sharpe rose to address them, speaking in soft
tones "so that his voidce was not heard beyond the building." According
to hylton:
"He (Sam Sharpe) then proceeded with a long address to thos around him
on various topics relating to the great subject he had on his heart, and with
an eloquence which kept all his hearers fascinated and spell-bount from the
beginning to the end of his speech. He referred to the namifold evils and injustice
of slavery; asserted the natural equality of man with regard to freedom; and
referring to hte Holy Scriptures as his authority, denied that the white mand
had any more right to hold the blacks in bondage than the blacks had to enslave
the white."
Although the style of the above quotation may differ from what Hylton repeated
in Beby, there is no doubt that the essence of Hylton's confession is authentically
recorded. Another participant of the 1831 rebellion was Captain Gardner, one
of Sharpe's commanders in the field. In his confession to Bleby, he told of
another meeting where Sharpe spoke to his followers. He states that on that
occasion:
"Sam Sharpe spoke for a long time on the subject of slavery and told us
what he had read in the papers concerning it; and he addressed us in such manner
that he (Gardner)was wrought up almost to a state of madness. After this speech
he entered in the freedom fighting with all his soul."
The above quotation show that Sam Sharpe was not just on ordinary slave, but
a man of extraordinary authority over his fellow slaves - a mand o charisma,
a religious leader, and an orator who commanded the attention of his audiences.
Bleby's description of Sam Sharpe shortly before his death is even more enlightening.
He wrote:
"Samuel Sharpe was a man whose active braing divised the project; and he
had sufficient authority with those around him to carry it into effect having
acquired an extraordinary degree of influence amongst his fellow-slaves."
Bleby went on to say, "He was the most intelligent and remarkable slave
I ever met with" He described Sam Sharpe as follows:
"Middle in size - fine sinewy frame - handsomely molded - his nos and lips
exhibited the usual characteristics of the negro race. He had teeth whose regularity
and pearly whiteness, a court-beauty micht have envied - and an eye whose brilliancy
was almost dazzling. He possessed intellectual and oratorical powers above the
common order."
And this, said Bleby, "was the secret of the extensive influence which
he exercisedl"
An Insight into Sharpe's charismatic powers (also rendered by Bleby) goes to
the heart of the character of this freedom fighter:
"I heard him (Sam Sharpe) tow or three times deliver a bried extemporaneous
address to his fellow-prisoners on religious topics, many of them being confined
together in the same cell; and I was amazed both at the power and freedom with
which he spoke, and at the effect which was produced upon his auditory. he appeared
to have the feelings and passion of his hearers completely at his command; and
when I listened to him once, I ceased to be surprised at what Gardner had told
me, "that when Sharpe spoke to him and others on the subject of slavery,"
he, Gardner, was "wrought up almost to a state of madness".
The sentence in Bleby's description of Sam Sharpe, which is most interesting
from a theoretical viewpoint reads: "He appeared to have ghe feelings and
passions of his hearers completely at his command." This peculiar ability
to command is the exclusive gift of the charismatic leader. Robert C. Tucker,
in his analysis of Charismatic leadership, states:
"Charismatic movements for change arise and spread at times when painful
froms of distress are prevalent in a society or in some particular stratum of
a society. The unique personal authority of the leader and the rapturous response
of many of his followers grow out of their feeling that he, by virtue of his
special powers as a leader, emodies the movement's salvational promise, hence
that which may be of spreme significance to tem. Since he ministers to their
most pressing need - the need to belive in the real possibility of excape from
an oppressive life predicament - they not only follow volutarily and without
thought of material recompense, but they tend to revere him and surround him
with that spontaneous cult of personality which appears to be one of the symptomatic
marks of the charismatic leader - follower relationship... Whereever,m and whenever
human beings in serious numbers live in desperation or despair or similar states,
charismatic leaders and movements are likely to appear."
The central cause of this rebellion (sometimes called the Baptist War) evolved
from Sharpe's assertion that the slaves' free papers had arrived and were being
withheld by the Planters' pressure on the governor of Jamaica. This idea was
circulated among the estates of St. James, Hanover, Westmoreland, and St. Elizabeth.
Sam Sharpe, it was reported, sent messengers to the estates to "spread
the news." This idea of free papers took on eschatological significance
similar to the messianic "day of the Lord" concept among the jews.
The prophet who was in touch with the source of the message -England- was Sam
Sharpe.
It may be helpful to consider what precipitates revolution, such as the one
in Jamaica. One of the major causes of revolution is the pesence of what the
social scientists call relative deprivation; that is, when a segment of the
society is deprived of the wealth and status enjoyed by another segment of society
because of race, religion, or sexual inferiority imposed by the privileged class.
In the Jamaica of the 1800s, this rype of social inequity might easily be considered
a cause of the rebellion, but the peculiar status of slaves prescribed by law
and the force of law would seem to preclude such an analysis. A more appropriate
theory (which fits rather uniquely with the Sam Sharpe rebellion) is one that
has received little attention: it posits that revolution is brought about by
a feeling of heightened expectation.
Whether this feeling of heightened expectation was created by Sam Sharpe, or
through the preaching of the Native Baptist Church, or thuough the preaching
of the Native Baptist Church, or through the behavior of the Planters is now
difficult to pinpoint. A fair evaluation would suggest a combination of all
these factors. Whatever the reason, most of the slaves in the county of Cornwall
had mentally, psychologically, and eschatologically ceased being slaves. The
decision was made by a large body of slaves not to return to work on any plantation
after the Christmas holidays of December 1831. On December 26, 1831, Bleby (the
missionary) reported taht he visited Ramble, a village in Westmoreland, and
learned that the slaves had a plan to cease work. As a typical Methodist minister,
Bleby implored his members "not to give heed to the unfounded and mischievous
reports that wree in circulation about their freedom having been given by the
King, and to have nothing to do with those persons who were disposed to create
mischief and lead them astray." He reported that all the slaves present
stood up and pledged themselves to act upon his advice. If we may belive the
records, it is generally agreed that the Methodist slaves never participated
in the Sam Sharpe rebellion. This is an awful commentary on the Jamaican Methodists
when compared with the freedom-fighting Methodists of the United States A very
different attitude was whown by the Baptists on the same day - December 26 -
when the Baptists Chapel at Slater's Hill near Montego Bay was dedicated. The
speaker was a reverend William Knibbs who, alluding to the gossip of impending
freedom which he sensed in the congregation, reported it as false. Bleby recalled:
"His remarks were met with evident dissatisfaction by many of the slaves
present, several of whom left the chapel offended, and others remaked that "the
man," meaning Mr. Knibbs, "must be mad to tell we such things".
Bleby concluded:
"the spirit and conduct of these negroes created n small alarm, and the
missionaries who were present on the occasion left the place with gloom and
painful foreboding."
Wah is suggested here is tha t"the spirit of heightened expectation"
cannot be satisfied with meaningless words, even if these words are facts. Given
the psychological state of the slaves, not even th governor of Jamaica could
convice them that they wre not to be freed. This was their faith, and faith
needs no proof. Freedom is not a thing given, it is a state of mind, and, as
this book will show, many of the slaves went to their death in freedom, even
without the "free papers"
The War
According to Bleby, Sam Sharpe's strategy was o start not a violent but a nonviolent
revolution. Life was not to be taken except in self-defence, but once the wrath
of oppresed peoples was set loose, it wsa not to be contained until, quoting
Bleby's words, "one of the fairest portions of this beautiful island was
laid to ruins."
So secretive were the preparations for the revold that now even teh keen eyes
of Bleby nor the suspicious Planters (who used every cunning to reveal the plot)
were able to discern signs of the imending upheavel. Bleby reported that after
the Ramble meeting and the dedicatoin of the Slater's Hill Baptist Church,
"Mr. Murray (a missionary colleague of his) proceeding to Montego Bay,
I to Lucea. Our way lay though in different directions, through the country
which was destined so soon to be laid waste; but at that time the most perfect
quiet prevailed. There was not visible the slightest indication of the storm
which was about to burst over our heads with such appalling and desolatory violence.
Sam Sharpe and his men had done their homework thoroughly, but only to a point.
If Sam Sharpe had intended only a nonviolent demonstration of solidarity against
slavery, some of his lieutenants did not get the message. As Bleby puts it:
"in the evening (of the same day) as it rew dark, the first indication
of ther actual revolt was given, by the burning of the houses and sugar-works
on a large plantation called "kensigton" the property of a Mr. Morris.
And soon after, the example was followed on other estates: so that all through
the night the heavens were lighted up by the burning properties in all directions"
It is believed that Kensington, situated on a hill, was used to sighal the slaves
that the insurrection had begun. What had been intended as a n onviolent protest
was not on the way to being one of the most violent slave uprisings in Jamaican
history.
Needless to say, the inhabitants of Montego Bay were seized with fear. For them,
the long-awaited day of judgment had come. With the example of Haiti fresh in
their minds, the White Planters took flight to the sea using every available
ship in port to escape with their women and children. the principal figure on
whom the Whites depended was one Mr. Grignon, an attorney, who acted as manager
of many estates whose owners lived in England. According to Bleby, he was one
of the most inhuman characters in the history of Jamaica slavery, with a habit
of using his slaves in such a way as to "discredit" the system! Bleby
believed that such behavior by an overseer was a primary abuse of the slave
system which finally brought disgrace to all! This rather mild rbuke, however,
showed the nisensitivity of Bleby himself. At the opening of the rebellion,
Gringnon assumed the role of colonel and hastily organised what was called the
Westen Interior Regiment, composed entirely of White Planters. This mustering
of White Planters was a slave tradition in which able-bodied Planters formed
their own regiments to defend their properties. They had two barracks for this
occasion - one at Belvidere Estate in Montego Bay and one at Shettlewood Estate
between the borders of St. James, St. Elizabeth, and Westmoreland. Initially,
two undred fifty of these men fomed into an army. But for some unknown reason,
Colonel Grignon retreated with his White Companions to Montpelier Estate (about
thirty miles from Montego Bay) instead of protecting the estates around Montego
Bay. Here on December 28, he was joined by the seventh Regiment of St. James
- a company made up entirely of Black soldiers - leaving Montego Bay and the
valuable plantations without protectoin. The slaves immediately proceeded to
wreak vengeance on the symbols of their oppression. One the evening of the twenty-eighth,
Sam Sharpe's army attacked Montpelier. Reporting on this confrontation, Bleby'
stated that the slaves' attack was accompanied by the blowing of horns and shells,
the noice of which so unnerved Colonel Grignon and his fellow planters-soldiers
that they were pettrified. Had i\t not been for the Black soldiers, the slaves
would have probably achieved their most dramatic victory.
The attack by the slaves was led by two Black colones: Johnson and Campbell.
Ine the fighting, johnson was killed and Campbell was mortally wounded. On the
Planter's side, all the fighting was done by the Black soldiers who alone were
brave enough to battle the insurgents. Bleby reported the, during the battle,
"Colonel Grignon and his entire regiment remained inactive, drawn up in
a hallow square leaving the Coloured company to fight it out with the Negroes
as best they could."
Unable to stand up against superior weapons, the slaves retreated. The coloured
Company who wanted to pursue the slaves into the interior - a plan which woud
have crushed the resistance early - was overruled by Colonel Grignon who decided
to play it safe and hastily retreated to Montego Bay. The retreat was so hasty
that theone White soldier who had been killed was left unburied. That same night
the slaves returned to burn down Montpelier; they took the White soldier out
of the hastily made coffing, committed him to the flames, and buried their leader
- Colonel Johnson - in it. Colonel Grignon later reported to the Governor that
he and his men were attacked by ten thousand men, who came down upon him in
four columns, but that he succeded in repulsing them. Bleby, who investigated
the matter, was satisfied that there were only five hundred slaves at most.
The Montpelier setback was a great blow to the rebellion, but the quick retreat
of the militia inflamed the slaves, and a renewed desire for freedom mounted.
Thousands of slaves joined rankswith the insurgents. All communications between
the principal towns were cut off and the entire country of Cornwell was in teh
hands of the slaves who set fire to all the estates in the parishes of St. James,
Hanover, Westmoreland, and St. Elizabeth. Bleby reported that not one white
man was to be seen from Montego Bay to Savanna la Mar, and from Black River
to Lucea. The militia was confined to the coastal towns of the north coast.
The day of reckoning, however, was approaching. As soon as news of the insurrection
had reached the governor in Spanish Town, martial law was declared; this meant
vengeance on the Blacks, both slaves and freed. The arrival of Genral Sir Willoughby
Cotton as commander in chief of the campaign, with the combined force of the
seventy-fourth, and eighty-fourth regiments, demonstrated the seriousness of
the conflict. Sensing the danger of a campaign against an army of slaves whose
spirits were high (and probably recalling the futility of fighting agains the
Maroons who knew the rugged mountains), Sir Willoughby issued a pardon to all
slaves willing to lay down arms and return to their fromer owners; only the
ringleaders were to be punished. The leniencyof the commander in chief reinforced
the slaves' belief that the king's army would do them no harm, and that slavery
had indeed been abolished. Bleby reported that the slaves greeted the English
ships with joy, believing that the soldiers had come to protect them. This misconception
was to be the doom of many who, upon hearing Genral Cuttons' proclamation, tried
to return to their former masters. Bleby reported sadly:"The proclamation
leniency was aborted by the gross revengeof the masters who used it as a lure
to delude unsuspecting slaves to their death." The worst was yet to come.
As soon as Sir Willoughby Cotton had left the scene of the conflict, slaves
returning to their masters were slaughtered indiscriminently. The bloodthirsty
repression on the part of the soldiers only caused the rebellion to be prolonged,
but now, the tide was turned against the slave population. This disadvantage,
as might be expected, was brought about by the slaves' lack of military equipment.
Their primary weapons were cutlasses, stones, homemade spears, and a few old
guns. They had no mutual plan of actoin, not ridi they have the military training
to stand against the disciplined veterans of the British Army.
Some of those who returned to the estates were killed, others were severely
flogged and reviled. But the larger number of the insurgents fled to the mountains.
These were hunted by small hands of soldiers who wreaded vengeance on them.
Most were hunted by the maroons who were paid to kill the fugitives and bring
their victims' ears as proof. So thoroughly did the Maroons perform their jobs
that Bleby referred to them as "demi-savages". The insurrection was
effectively over.
The Aftermath
During and after the period of martial law, the revenge of the landed gentry
was unremitting. Thousands of slaves were put to death after trial by court-martial,
first by the bullets of the fireing squad, and later by the gallows which was
erected inthe town square of Montego Bay. Bleby, and eyewitness of these atrocities,
told of crowds of condemned slaves who were hanged: half an hour elapsed between
sentencing and death. Bleby's sensitive conscience was disturbed by this unusual
haste to snuff out the lives of the insurrectionists. He asked rhetorically:
"What was the motive of this indecent and inhuman haste, I do not pretend
to determine. The only reason i can suggest apart from a thirst for blood, which
it was horrible to witness, is this - that, after the military began at last
to move, such multitudes of prisonners were sent in from the country, that there
was no place in which to secure them: the goals became over-crowded to excess,
and perhaps it was considered necessary to make room for the new arrivals by
putting as may as possible out of the way."
But the real reason was a "thirst for blood". As Bleby rightly observed,
the officers of the militia and the membes of the court-martial - those who
captured and sentenced the slaves to death - were the very men who regarded
the insurrectionists the culprits of their ruin. For weeks, the galows were
seldom empty. Generally, four hung at once; their bodies remained stiffening
in the breeze until the court-martial board supplied another batch of victims
for the hands of Bacchus - the name of the Black slave who acted as executioner.
Bleby made some important notes on the mental and emotional attitudes of the
condemned:
"the undaunted bravery and fortitude with which many of the insurgents
met their fate formed a very remarkable feature in the transactions of the period:
and strikingly indicated the difficulty attendant upon the maintenance of slaver,
now that the spirit of freedom had gone abroad, and many of the negroes had
learn to prefer death to bondage."
bleby was moved by the bravery and clmness with which many met their death:
"Not even a muscle was seen to quiver and the dignified bearing with which
many met their death showed clearly that they were untroubled with any misgivings
as to bhe justice of their cause."
No real figure of the carnage was ever disclosed. After martial law was lifted
and kiling was forbidden in the public square, the slaughter continued unabated
on the estates, where condemned slaves were sent to their death in secret. The
last man to die was Samuel Sharpe. He was executed in Montego Bay on May 23,
1832. According to Bleby who spoke with him, Sharpe was, until the last, rather
regretful of th edeath and destruction his plan had caused, but "he was
not however, to be convinced that he had done wrong in endeavoring the assert
his claim to fredom."
Bleby, who witnessed Sharpe's death along with hundreds of others, recounted
the scene:
"He marched to the spot whre so many had been sacrificed to the demon of
slavery, with a firm and even dignified step - clothed in a suit of new white
clothes. He seemed to be unmoved by the near approach of death. In a few moments
the executioner had done his work, and the noble-minded originator of this unhappy
revolt ceased to exist."
As a footnote, Bleby added "He was such a man, too, as was likely, nay,
certainly, had he been set fre, to commence another struggle for freedom."
The spirit of freedom could only be contained briefly, for Sam Sharpe's image
continued to inspire Jamaicans from that day to the present. Today, this spirit
is seen in the Rastafarian movement and in the Manley government which has renamed
the square in which Sam Sharpe was executed as Sam Sharpe Square, thus giving
dignity to one of Jamaica's martyrs for freedom. But the honor paid him was
only anticlimatic in view of the real victrory which his death brought about.
Soon after the death of Sam Sharpe, slavery itself was dead. Within two years
of his death, th eabolition of slavery was proclaimed thoughout the British
colonies and a new era in Jamaican history was begun. The chains were now loose
from the feet of the sons of Africa and their seardch fro a place in the sun
commenced - a search which was to encounter more obstacles, as the rest of the
story will reveal.
The Morant Bay Rebellion, 1865
The abolition of slavery in 1834 left Jamaica in a state of chaos. The transition
envisaged for slaves, based on an apprenticeship system intended to displace
slave labor with a wage-earning economy, was an ideal based on the good will
of the Planters and the slaves' willingness to work. The nature of society proffered
this dream without the means to implement it. For one thing, the Planters, though
heavily reimbursed for the loss of their slaves, still held a deep resentment
toward the Imperial Government for upsetting their way of life through the emancipation,
and they resented all instructions from England. On the other hand, the freed
slaves resented all aspects of forced labor, the Planters, and hte plantations.
Their primary interest was to keep alive by working their small provision grounds
and to enjoy their newly-won freedom as long as possible. On top of it all,
religious and political refalry made Jamaica intoa churning caldron of hate.
On the one side, the Church of England and the masters were deeply resentful
of the Methodists and Baptists who championed the welfare of the slaves, most
of the freed Blacks, and the rising colored elites. To these was added a marginal
group of religionists known as the Native Baptists and the Revivalists whose
revolutionary tendency threatened the status quo. As indicated in the previous
discussion of the Sam Sharpe Rebellion, it was within this marginal group that
the spirit of revolution was nurtured, and form this group the dynamics of the
Morant Bay Rebellion would find expression and support. The attitude toward
the Native Baptists was expressed by a contemporary of the period as:
" (A) place in which ignorance and superstition are enthroned - the hot-bed
in which Obeahism and Myalism and other heathen practices attain their most
vigorous growth and where the grossest impurity and vice are found in strange
and unnatural alliance with a profession of the pure religion of Christ."
We need no other documentation of the attitude of the establishment toward the
Native Baptists, but it will be useful to keep in mind that both G. Wiliam Gordon
and Paul Bogle, the two heroes of the Morant Bay Rebellion, were ministers of
the Native Baptist Church of Jamaics.
The Setting
The tree main figures around whom the Morant Bay Rebellion was played out were
the English Governor Edward John Eyre, the Jamaican mulatto elitist George William
Gordon, and the Black Baptist deacon-preacher Paul Bogle. These men represented
three different worlds in nineteenth-century Jamaica. Governor Eyre (after yuears
of mediocre work which included exploring in Australia, sheep raising in New
Zealand, and a lieutenant governorship in St. Vincent) was sent to Jamaica in
March, 1862, as a temporary replacement for Governor Darling - a position which
became permanent when Governor Darling was appointed to another post. Eyre,
the son of an Anglican minister and a man of rather modest attainment, came
to Jamaica - as the record showed - "in hope to distinguish himself".
whether this hope was ever fulfilled is a matter of interpretation. If murdering
human beings is a distinguising characteristic, he has, without question, highly
distinguished himself in this accomplishment. But the historical opinion of
him in Jamaica, and his long and agonizing trials in England for his acts in
Jamaica, leave no doubt in the minds of his English contemporaries and the world
that his appointment to Jamaicawas one of the more regrettable episodes in British
colonial history.
As governr, he was placed in an ill-fitting situation. In the second half of
the nineteenth century, Jamaica was one of the most difficult islands to administer.
governor Eyre's appointment, being temporary, carried no real power for decision
making at a time when strong and firm leadership was desperately needed to cope
with the powerful conflicts which existed. His salary - a mere pittance - placed
him in an odd position amid a snobbish, though waning, aristocrazy of Planters
and an affluent colored middle class of merchants and lawyers. As a high church
Anglican, he had little respect for the sectarians and absolutely disdained
the native cults. these elements were later to emerge in a fatl combination
for the Black Jamaicans to whom Eyre was by nature unable to relate. It is in
this light that we must see the unfolding of the Morant Bay debacle.
One of hte men with whom Eyre was forced to deal was a radical politician, a
self-ordained minister of the Native Baptist Church, and a wealthy landowner
named William Gordon. Gordon was born in 1818, the son of Joseph Gordon, a White
attorney, and a slave mother. His father - a politician and one time custos
of St. Andrew - was the owner of the Cherry Gardens Estate, now a beautiful
suburb in the foothills overlooking Kingston. Gordon was one of seven illegitimate
children who was freed with his mother by his father. Young Gordon was brought
up in Black River with his godfather, james Daley. He received no formal education
but was able to pick up a great knowledge of business in Daley's store where
he worked. At eighteen, he was back in Kingston in a business of his own where
he prospered so well that, in 1843, he was reported to have been worth ten thousand
pounds. In 1848, he was proprietor of four estates, one being Cherry Gardens
which he bought from his father. It is said that although he was never allowed
to enter his father's house, he was always kind to the old man who, in his old
age and having fallen on bad days, had his passage back to England paid by young
Gordon.
Depending on the sources one reads, Gordon was reported to be a crooked man;
an owner of slaves, whom he treated badly; a hypocrite; an obeahman; and a shylock.
Others saw him as man of unbounded benevolence and a champion of the dispossessed,
a brillian orator, and deeply religious. We may now easily ignore the negative
descriptions of the man - in those days to be a member of the Native Baptist
Church and a champion of the dispossessed were enough to brand anyone a revolutionary.
Socially, Gordon was highly placed among the colored merchants of his day and
was wealthy enough to be elected to the House of Assembly in 1850 as a member
of Town Party. Originally, he seems to have been a member of the Presbyterian
Church, but later became a Native Baptist in the mass conversion of the 1861
revival. He married Lucy Shannon, the daughter of a White school principal and
appears to have had a good marriage before his untimely end. We are also told
that he established a tabernacle in Kingston and ordained various deacons there,
among whom was Paul Bogle of Stony Gut of St. Thomas-in-the-east. The connection
between these two men will soon become clear.
As politician and champion fo the dispossessed, it was not long before Gordon
began to attack the leadership of Governor Eyre. Gordon felt Eyre was insensitive
to the needs of the poor. His open attack of the governor and the House of Assembly
- in what would still be called unguarded speech - won him no friends among
his White colleagues with whom the governor had become quite friendly. The governor
and the House of Assembly taxed the poor beyond their capacity, thereby forcing
them to return to the estates. Gordon's political downfall began with an incident
inSt. Thomas where, because of his vast holdings in real estate, he was made
a magistrate of that parish. In 1862, he sent an open letter to the governor
complaining about the abnormal conditions of poverty and official reglect of
the Blacks in that parish. This letter was taken as an insult to the established
church, whose rectory was head of the vestry - a body cmpowered to look after
the welfare of the people, and a body of which Gordon himself was a member.
This attack on the establised churh and the White Plantes gave Eyre his chance
to revenge his accuser. Gordon was summarily dismissed rom his post as magistrate.
This dismissal came as a blow to Gordon's pride. His tirades against the governor
became increasingly vitriolic. Hated bgy the governor, the Planters and the
church Gordon aserted himself as the messianic leader of the Blacks and colored
with one intention- self -government by Blacks.
An example of Gordon's fercefulnes is preserved in the biography of Edward John
Eyre by Hamilton Hume. In a parlimentary debate on conditions in Jamaica in
1865, Grodon actaully prophesied the coming rebellion in a rebuttal of his opponents.
the following is an excerpt:
"Mr. Gordon: It does not seem that his excellincy's natural endowments
qualify him for the government of this country. ICries of "Order")
I desire to give honour to whom honour is due, and I respect every man in authority,
but if a ruler does not sway the sword with justice, he becomes distasteful,
and instead of having the love and respect of the people, he becomes despised
and hated. All the privileges, all the rights, and all the purposes of the constitution
should be maintained in their hightest integrity and purity, by the gentlemen
who may from time to time be entrusted with the government of this country.
So soon as he digresses from this, so soon does he descend from his high position,
and become grovelling, portentous (sic) and prevaricating.
Mr. Speaker: Order! The language of the honourable member cannot beallowed.
The honourable gentleman meus know that he is out of order.
Mr. Gordon: I regret, Mr. Speaker, that I am out of order, but when every day
we witness the mal-administration of the law by the Lieutenant-governor, we
must speak out. You are endeavouring to suppress public opinion, to pen up the
expresoin of public indignation; but I tell you that it will soon burst forth
like a flood, and sweep everything before it. There must be a limit to oppression
- a limit to transgression - and a limit to illegality! These proceedings remind
me of the time of Herod - they remind me of a tyrannical period of history!
I do not think that any Government has ever acted so before. While he justifies
humself in one case, he uses the police force to accomplish another illegality.
What an example to the prisoners who are confined in prison! If the lieutenant
-governor is to go on in this way, what can you expect from the populace?
Mr. Lewis: Insurrection (laughter)
Mr. Gordon: Ay! that will be the result... "
This small sample of Gordon's proclamations demonstrates his bodl attack on
teh status quo and clearly suggests the burden he felt for his country. It also
suggests that things were not going well with the populace. The clear warning
in this parliamentary discussion would son break loose in Jamaica. His use of
the word "portentous" instead of "pretentious" was rather
prophetic as we now review the tragic outcome of Eyre's governorship.
We need to know a little more about the social and economic conditions in the
year 1865, and for this we must turn to a letter written by Mr Edward B. Underhill;
Mr. Underhill visited Jamaica shortly before the rebellion. This letter was
addressed to the Honorable Mr. Edward Cardwell, M.P., England's Secretary of
State for the Colonies during the governorship of Eyre. The letter is commonly
believed to be one fo the documents that encouraged the rebellion. After his
usual salutation to the colonial secrtetary, he began:
"I venture to ask your kind consideration to a few observations on the
present condition of the Island of Jamaica... Crime has fearfully increased.
The number of prisoners in th epenitentiary and gaols is considerably more than
double the average, and nearly all for one crime: larceny. Summons for petty
debts disclose an amount of pecuniary difficulty which has never before been
experienced; and application for parochial and private relief prove that multitudes
are suffering from want, a little removed from starvation."
Mr. Underhill then went on to describe the naked conditions of people who, accustomed
to dressing modestly, waled around in rags scarcely sufficient to cover their
private parts. Even though he saw this condition resulting from the steep rise
in cotton, he attributed it to the gross mismanagement of the island's economy
and, more specifically, to the lack of employment; on an island of four hundred
thousand people, only thirty thousand were employed on the sugar estates. Then
pointing direclty to what he thoughtt to be the source of the problems he wrote:
"I shall say nothing of the course taken by the Jamaica Legislature; of
their abortive immigration bills; of their unjust taxation of the coloured populatoin;
of their refual of just tribunals; of their denial of political rights to the
emancipated negroes."
He then proceeded to suggest a sweeping inquiry into the Jamaica legislature
since emancipation, the need for the development of native products, and new
ways of utilizing the land for agriculture other than cane and sugar. For example,
he saw such minor products as spices, tobaco, farinceous doofs, coffee, and
cotton as excellent possibilities for Jamaica, if the proper incetive were given
by the government. (this suggestion, incidently, remains a prime need for present-day
Jamaica.) Mr. Underhill closed with a warning:
"It is more than time that the unwisdom (to use the gentlest term) that
has governed Jamaica since emancipation should be brought to en end - a course
of action which, while in incalculably aggravates the misery arising from natural,
and, therefore, unavoidable causes, renders crtain the ultimate ruin of every
class, planter and peasants, European and Creole."
This letter was forwarded to Governor Eyre in Jamaica, who cirulated it to the
custodes and heads of religious denominations. As a member of the legislature,
G.W. Gordon was probably the first to get a copy of it. As expected, almost
all the leading men in Jamaica denied that conditions were as bad as the letter
describing them. A sweeping defense of teh establishment was launched by those
who controlled the power. But for G.W. Gordon, this only confirmed his assessment
of the island situation, and, armed with the support of this letter from an
Englishman who told it like it was, he began to urge the common people to resist
their domination. His burning zeal for a better Jamaica caused him to use insurrectionary
language, which could do little but inflame the oppressed. His speeches were
later to be the cause of his death. But we must now introduce the other hero
of the rebellion.
Paul Bogle
In a bill of description published for the capture of Bogle after the Morant
Bay Rebellion, he was describedas "very black, shiney of skin, heavy marks
of smallpox on face, expecially on nose; good teeth - large mouth, red thick
lips; about five feet eight inces tall, broad shoulders; carries himself idoently,
with no whiskers." I found no information about his place of birht or the
circumstances surrounding his childhood. but it is reported that he was the
owner of a large piece of land in the hill country of St. Thomas, in a village
named stony gut, six miles from Morant Bay. He was closely connected with G.W.
Gordon who was reported to have baptized him in his Kingsont Tabernacle, where
he was ordained either as a preacher or a deacon in the year of the rebellion,
1865. Records of Bogle's involvement with Gordon are rather scarce, but there
is no doubt that they both had close religious ties and that both were champions
of the dispossessed. Gordon was a man of words and, like Sam Sharpe, could stir
his audience to a state of madness; Paul Bogle was a man of action who was not
afraid to confront the establishment with a show of strength.
It now appears that the September, 1865, Boble had made up his mind to cross
the Rubican of Jamaica's long years of oppression, and to risk his life in an
attack on Morant Bay. But he feared the Maroons. In that same month he was reported
to have met with Major sterling of the Windward Maroons who received him but
gave him no definite answer. However, the ambiguity of the Maroons's answer
led Bogle tobelieve that if a campaign were launched, he could depend on them.
This was a gross mistake - the history of Jamaican revolts should have been
too fresh in Bogle's mind for him to have been so duped. It also appears that
the Maroons were well aware of the plans for the rebellion and that they had
already given their allegiance to the government. Meanwhile, at his Baptist
Chapel at Stony Gut, Bogle began to make his not-so-secret preparation by drillin
his mountain recruits in military operations. His plan was to march on Morant
Bay with an army of men to show his strength. On October 7 (a market day), he
marched into town at the head of two undred men, with fife and drum and an assortment
of weapons.
What took place that day in Morant Bay could not have been the only reason for
his long march with two undred men. The demonstration, however, provided the
real spark for the historic rebellion which followed. On reaching the court
house, it is said, Bogle left his soldiers in the public square and entered
the court house where tow minor cases were being tried. The case of cases must
have been of some interest to Bogle, or perhaps it was simply a coincidence.
The eventual incident was triggered by a youngn man who became mildly abusive
to the magistrate when a convict was charged for crimes committed on a woman.
His conduct would have caused him to be apprehended by the police as he attempted
to leave the court, had it not been for Bogle's intervention. Poorly documented,
this very insignificant skirmish is about all that took place, although there
is ome indication tha tBogle's men did "rough-up" a few policemen.
Bogle thus was technically guilty of obstructing the police fom performing their
duty. He cold also have been charged with disorderly conduct.
To get a clearer picture of Morant Bay, it might be of some interest to introduce
the leading men who served th colonial government in St. Thomas. One of the
men closely connected with the Gordon and Bogle controversy was the Reverend
Stephen Cooke, Anglican rector of Morant Bay adn president of the vestry (a
sort of parochial council). Another man, the custos of the parish, the Honorable
Maximilian Augustus, Baron von Ketelhodt, had come to Jamaica in the 1830s and
became a Jamaican citizen in 1839 after marrying a rich widow; he owned five
pantations, mostly in St. Thomas. He and Mr. Gordon were avowed enemies. Baron
von Ketelhodt was to play a prime roel in the whole episode. The third man was
the Reverend V. Herschell, curator of Bath in St. Thomas. Many others made important
contributions to the rebellion, but these three were G.W Gordon't sompanions
on the vestry, and all were to become figures in the historical drama.
Soon after Bogle and his men returned to their homes in the hills, warrants
were issued for the arrest of Bogle, his brother, and twenty-five other men
on charges of rioting and of assaulting the police. Eight police were sipatched
to Stony gut to appehend them. It si now easy to srumise what took place over
one hundred years ago, but the idea of sending wight police to an area from
which two undred armed men had come was either conceived by an inexperienced
civil servant, or the episode was designed to have Bogle commit himself. The
fate of this apprehending party can easily be imagined. they were severely beaten,
and, had they been White soldiers, they would have been killed. The police were
forced to take an oath on the Bible that they would fight on the Blacks; after
this they were set free.
While in Stony Gut, the police overheard that Bogle's army had planned to march
on the town the following day, October 10, 1865. On earning of the planned march,
Baron von Ketelhodt dispatched a message to Governor Eyre and alerted the Morant
Bay police. In the letter he added the following postscript: "The shells
are at this moment blowing to collect men all through St. John's." (This
blowing of shell and horns was a practise of the maroons in time of war.) Then
he added, "Gordon's inflammatory speeches had borne fuit earlier than I
least anticipated." On the 10th, Paul Bogle at the head of several hundred
men, marched into town and attacked the vestry. Eighteen persons were killed,
mostly White, among whom were Baron von Ketelhodt and the Reverend Heschell.
Thirty-one were wounded and fifty-one prisoners were freed from jail. Bogle
and his men tok the prisoners to Stony Gut, where Bogle held a prayer meeting
to thank God for his victory.
By the time Baron von Ketelhodt's letter had reached Governor Eyre, the Baron
was already dead. Preparations were made to dispatch men to Morant Bay on the
H.M.S Wolverine and the Onyx - both anchored on Port Royal. Late on October
10, Governor Eyre heard that the massacre had taken place and he sailed from
Port Royal on the French ship Caravelle to survey the situation in person. On
his way to Morant Bay, he met the Wolverine returning with a cargo of refugees
and got firsthand report of the dimensions of the war. Meanwhile, Paul Bogle
and his men were on the move. The town of Bath was raken on the twelfth of October,
but this move was the beginning of the end for the Bogle rebellion. At the request
of the magistrate of Bath, the Maroons joined the conflict against Bogle. This
was a mortal blow. On October thirteenth, martial law was declared for the county
of Surrey which inclided St. Thomas, Portland, and St. George, Kingston was
excluded. Ont the fourteenth, court-marthial was instituted at Morant Bay and
the British military mill of martial law began its day-by-day extinctin of human
life. Dutton states that the aim of martial law was the restoration of law and
order, but the method used to achieve this goal was terror. It was license to
flog and kill subjected citizens of the colonies. Eyre's martial law was a monster
that he was unable to control. The 1831 rebellion in the county of Cornwall
was a model for Surrey. Martial law continued for thirty days and with the help
of the Maroons, whose loyalty for the Crown never waivered, the militia (numbering
nearly fifteen hundred, most of whom wre experienced in the historical campaigns
of Great Britain's farflung empire) brutally crushed the rebellion. As many
as a thousand people were killed, including George William Gordon and Paul Bogle;
over a thousand cottages owned by rebels were burned and, in all this, there
is no evidence that any sailors or soldiers wre killed after the initial eighteen
at Morant Bay.
Governor Eyre blamed the cause of the rebellion on Gordon and ordered his arrest.
Dutton reported Eyre as saying:
"There is on e very importatn point to be decided upon. Throughout my tour
in the Wolverine and the Onyx I found everywhere the most unmistakable evidence
that Mr. Geo. Wm. Gordon, a coloured member of the House of Assembly, had not
only been mixed up in the matter, but was himself, through his own misrepresentation
and seditious language addressed to teh ignorant black people, the chief cause
and origin of the whole rebellion."
Gordon was not in Morant Bay on the day of teh rebellion (he was sick at home",
but his speeches had implicated him and, as Eyre stated:
"Having obrtained a deposition on oath that certain seditious printed notices
(Gordon's proclamation "state of the island" had been sent through
the Post Office directed, in his handwriting, to parties who have been leaders
in the rebelloin, I at once called upon the Custos to issue a warrant and capture
him"
Gordon, learntin of the arrest warrant turned himself in to the officials in
Kingston. He should have been tried in a civil court becaus he was not arrested
in an area where martial law was declared, but Eyre himself accompanied Gordon
in the Wolverine to Morant Bay where there was no law, fearin he would have
won his casein Kingston. Here he was tried by three junior officers and found
guilty of high treason and complicity in a rebellion. This case was to be Eyre's
downfall. This farce of justice was so illegal that it brought a hurricane of
legal entanglements on the governor, involving some of h greatest legal minds
in England. On October 22, 1865, George William Gordon was hanged at the Morant
Bay Court House. He denied his complicity in the rebellion to the last. Paul
Bogle was captured on teh same day by the Maroons at Stony Gut. In his trial
he refused to implicate Gordon and at 5 p.m. on the twenty-fourth of October,
he was hanged from the yardarm of H.M.S. Wolverine. With the deaths of Gordon
and Bogle, two more freedom fighters in the Jamaican liberation struggle had
left their indelible marks on history.
The rebellion was not at all in vain. The fear it brought about was so overpowering
and portentous of future troubles that the Planters, the most obstreperous and
loggerheaded individuals of the Britis colonies, finally submitted to the end
of their privileges. On December 22, 1865, "the 202-year-old representative
institution of Jamaica ended, and became a Crown Colony." the privileges
of the oligarchy wre put to an end, thanks to Gordon and Bogle. It was another
two centuries before moderate independence was accorded to Black Jamaicans,
but th rule of tyrany was overthrown by the Morant Bay rebellion.
Crown Colony to Independence 1865 - 1962
This section will give only an outline of the social, political economic developments
from 1865 to 1962, when Jamcaica became an independent nation of the British
Commonwealth.
Faced with a society it could no longer dominate, the Jamaican Assembly surrendered
the old constitution and became a crown colony. Under the new constitution the
real power of decision-making now rested with the governor advised by a cabinet
which controlled the legislative council. In this council, the governor enjoyed
a permanent majority of nominated officials over elected members. By 1884, the
members of the legislative council were elected, of which the overwhelming majority
were White. However, this new constitution had built-in guidelines which anticipated
the inevitable hour when the Black majority would seize power. It stipulated
that the success of the government would dpend on a maintenance of reasonable
economic and social conditions. If, however, the governor and the members of
the legislative council failed to maintain friendly working relatiosn, and if
the economic life of Jamaica were to suffer from acute depression, leading perhaps
to labor violence, or if the overwhelmingly large Black element in the population
should become conscious of its inferior position and find capable leaders with
a positive democratic program - then the political constitution might have to
be amended or abolished to meet the new conditions.
Despite the new constitution, the political climate form 1884 on remainded as
lethargic as before, perpetuated by apathy and disdain toward the Black population.
Not until 1920 to 1921, under the leadership of Marcus Mosiah Garvey, did the
Black population begin to show some political consciousness.
Encouraged bye the awakening consciousness brought on by Garvey, Jamaican expatriates
in New York, who were members of the Jamaica Progressive League under the leadership
of Mr. W. Adolphe Roberts, began to exhort Jamaicans to:
"... begin to act as peole within the framework of hte Empire and cease
speaking - or even thinking - as apathetic subjects under a Crown Colony system
which has long oulived its time. The inhabitants of Jamaica are, in fact, a
people. The awakening of a consciousness of nationality is what is needed today."
The exhortation to sense a "consciousness of natinoality" met with
genuine response. Definite interest now began to develop in political matters,
with citizens' associations forming in the Kingston area to organize discussions
on public matters. But the turning point in Jamaica's political development
came in 1938 - violence again acting as stage director - when labor unrest came
to a head in the parish of Westmoreland at the Tate and Lyle sugar Factory,
followed by labor unrest in Spanish Town and Kingston. Serious violence, put
down by an armed constabulary with the loss of many lives, brought Jamaican
conditions to th attention of the imperial government, which appointed a Royal
Commission under the leadership of Lord Moyne. The colonial mentality is peculiarly
myopic; it can act only by violence or the threat of it on the part of the Blacks.
Lord Moyne's report recommended the need for a new constitution as a basis of
the future development of self-government. Jamaican independence was a direct
result of that far-reaching report.
The 1938 rebellion saw the emercence of the learned barrister-politicians, Norman
W. Manley, and the flamboyand Alexander Bustamante, who set in motion the two
political parties which have steered jamaica to its present status. Sir Alexander
Bustamante died in 1977, but is still revered by all jamaicans. the Honorable
Norman Manley is now dead, but the mantle of Jamaican leadership was also worn
by his charismatic son, Michael Manley, whose dedication to the dispossessd
and whose dislike for those who sit in the citadels of privilege is well known.
In no other politician has the spirit of G.W. Gordon been so thoroughly reincarnated
as it is in Michael Manley, except possibly the national hero, Marcus Mosiah
Garvey.
Garvey and the Rastafarians
We shall conclude this chapter with a short analysis of the influence of the
back-to-africa movement inspired by Marcus Garvey in Jamaica, and see what connections
exist between the demise of the Universal Negro Improvement Association and
the rise of the present-day Rastafarians.
Marcus Mosiah Garvey, one of the world's most renowned Black leaders, was born
in the parish of St. Ann in 1887, just twenty-two years after the Morant Bay
rebellion. His childhood and early manhood coincided with that period of Jamaican
history in which political apathy in the Black population - due to restrictiosn
on black expression by the ruling class - was at its highest. Social and economic
stagnation was widespread. The yoke of colonialism was secure on the island
and in Africa as well. Every aspect of Jamaican life was dominated by the Europeans,
and there was very little hope for native Jamaicans to improve their position.
Despite this context, Garvey was no ordinary man, but one of those rare creatures
of history whose fate it is to be seized wth the social and economic oppressoin
of a people and who see this oppression as his or her own spiritual mission.
His middle name, Mosiah or Moses, was a portentous appellation - to deliver
his people from the yoke of colonialism was to be his lifelong strugle. No other
Black man in history was able to understand so clearly the worldwide oppressions
of Black people, and no other was in turn perceived by so many Blacks as the
one person with the solutin to their problems.
Garvey's personality took on messianic proportiosn to Blacks in Jamaica, the
United States, and Africa, resulting in the formation of a movement aroundhim.
In 1914, the organized the Universal Negro Improvement Association in Kingston,
a movement that was to change the self-image of Blacks all over the world. but
since "A prophen is not withou honour, but in hsi own country," Marcus Garvey had to leave Jamaica in order to prusue his dreams. First, he wanted
a worldwide confraternity fo the Black race; second he wished to see the development
of Africa from a backward, colonial enclave to a self-supporting giant of which
all Blacks could be proud; tird he wanted to see Africa as a developled Negro
nation, a force in world power, and a place to which all Blacks cold return;
he envisioned a black nation from which black representatives were to be sent
to all the principal countries and cities of the world; fifth, he wanted to
see the development of black educational institutions for the teaching of Black
curltures; and last, he wanted to work for the uplifting of the Black race anywhere
it was to be found.
In Jamaica, Garvey's dreams were unaccepted. Though he developed a large following,
official opposition to his program came from both blacks and whites. The whites
viewed him as a threat to Pax Britannica and the blacks, expecially those of
hte middle class, felt themselves beyond the class of a man like Garvey. His
success as a leadr was to come in the United States. His demonstrated abilities
as a leader in a foreign country later gave him legitimacy in his homeland.
Jamaica has since made him a national hero.
The ethos of the Garvey movement did not wane with his death. His philosophy
- "Africa for the African at home and abroad" - was to be taken up
by various Black movements after him; one of these is the Jamaican Rastafarians.
It is often repeated among the Rastafarians that, just before Marcus Garvey
left for the United States in 1916, he is reported to have said in his farewell
address, "look to Africa for the crowning of a Black King, he shall be
the Redeemer." To the Rastafarians this king was Haile
Selassie. Today,
all Rastafarians revere Marcus Garvey as their inspirer; his picture is prominent
in all homes and cult houses. His speeches are avidly read; songs and poems
are written in his honor and, in the pantheon of the Rastafarians, Marcus Garvey
is second on ly to Haile
Selassie.
We have sollowed the long and bloody road that Jamaica and its people have traveled
from the seventeenth century to the present. Despite the great price in death
and suffering Jamaicans underwent in this struggle, their resistance to domination
has never faltered. the fight or flight syndrom of hte Jamaicand personality
represents a cultural experience which has become a permanent part of the people's
psyche. The Rastafarian movement is the most recent expression of this national
character.
|